Talk:List of unreleased Marilyn Manson projects

From MansonWiki, the Marilyn Manson encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the List of unreleased Marilyn Manson projects article.
This is not a forum for general discussion about the article's subject.

  • Assume good faith.
  • Be welcoming.
  • No personal attacks.

Nine(?) Unreleased Eat Me, Drink Me B-Sides[edit]

The person who decides to include the point about there being 9 completed tracks remaining from the Eat Me, Drink Me sessions again should also include a reference. I can find no evidence online that Manson has ever stated that there were 9 remaining (and completed) leftovers from those sessions - nor have I ever read of his intentions to release them, rework them, etc. All I could find was the interview on MansonUSA - where he commented that 2 (TWO!) completed songs were remaining and were in contention for a place on the album. "9" is complete bullshit.

The article says nine confirmed b-sides and leftovers. It doesn't say nine absolutely complete but unreleased songs, it simply states that nine pieces of music recorded during these sessions exist but have yet to see release. Windstorm 06:27, 26 October 2008 (UTC)

A Movie based on Eat Me, Drink Me[edit]

Again, can anyone actually recall Manson saying anything along these lines? Which movie? Phantasmagoria? The live DVD? A story based on EMDM? If it's the later, that's complete bullshit. Post proof.

Manson stated exactly the latter in an interview posted by The Hierophant while Eat Me, Drink Me was still hot. It's unlikely that the film is a project he will take up now, but to call bullshit on these words coming out of Manson's mouth is absurd. Hardly anything has been given a direct source here, but that doesn't mean the wiki's administrators would actually let false information like this slip through. Windstorm 06:27, 26 October 2008 (UTC)

A Proposal...[edit]

I propose this article be further modified to include phrases such as "Confirmed to Exist/Be in Production" and "Assumed" as the main field titles. "Compass and the Ruler" and "Jack Eats Dinner" could just as easily be Golden Age out-takes - as they first appeared on a video clip posted on marilynmanson.net sometime late '02, around the same time as the "Making Of New Shit" video (the one where the guy from the Make A Wish Foundation was doing backup vocals). Plus, they could very easily be the wrong song titles. Those 2 songtitles only ever appeared on the ASCAP website and could easily be unreleased tracks made for the Resident Evil score (they appeared around the same time as the rest of the RE score song titles).

Plus, he never expressly mentioned that he was working or even wanted to release a Part Deux to Long Hard Road Out Of Hell.

Homeostasis. 04:12, 26 October 2008 (UTC)

Again, a Hierophant report of an interview with Manson last year indeed revealed he was interested in possibly penning a followup to The Long Hard Road Out of Hell. Windstorm 06:27, 26 October 2008 (UTC)